Luigi's Mansion Review

"A hauntingly charming launch title that proved Luigi could carry his own adventure. While short, it delivers atmosphere, personality, and gameplay innovation that still holds up over two decades later."

By Anthony Micallef Published on 9/14/2001

A Spooky New Direction

When the GameCube launched in 2001, fans expected another Mario adventure. Instead, Nintendo surprised everyone by putting his eternally nervous brother in the spotlight. Luigi's Mansion was a bold departure from the platforming formula, trading jump puzzles for ghost hunting in a haunted mansion.

The premise is simple but effective: Luigi wins a mansion in a contest he never entered, only to discover it's overrun with ghosts. Armed with the Poltergust 3000 vacuum cleaner (courtesy of the eccentric Professor E. Gadd), Luigi must capture ghosts room by room while searching for his missing brother Mario.

Gameplay That Sucks (In a Good Way)

The core gameplay loop is surprisingly satisfying. You stun ghosts with your flashlight, then vacuum them up while they struggle to escape. It's like a ghostly tug-of-war, and the dual-stick controls (one for movement, one for aiming) were revolutionary for their time.

The mansion itself is a puzzle box waiting to be unlocked. Each room presents unique challenges, from finding hidden keys to solving environmental puzzles. The portrait ghosts – special boss-like spirits with distinct personalities and weaknesses – are the real highlights. Each requires you to figure out their weakness before you can capture them.

Technical Showcase

Luigi's Mansion was designed to demonstrate the GameCube's capabilities, and it shows. The real-time lighting effects were groundbreaking – Luigi's flashlight casts dynamic shadows, candles flicker realistically, and the transition from dark to lit rooms is genuinely impressive. Even today, the art direction holds up remarkably well.

The attention to detail is remarkable. Luigi hums nervously along to the background music, his teeth chatter when he's scared, and he calls out "Mario?" in increasingly worried tones. These small touches give the game an incredible amount of personality.

The Elephant in the Room

The biggest criticism of Luigi's Mansion is its length. A skilled player can complete it in about 4-5 hours on a first playthrough. While the Hidden Mansion mode (unlocked after beating the game) offers increased difficulty, it doesn't fundamentally change the experience enough to warrant multiple replays.

For a launch title priced at full retail, this was a tough pill to swallow in 2001. Today, with used copies readily available, the value proposition is much better – but it's still a factor to consider.

Legacy

Luigi's Mansion spawned a beloved franchise. The 3DS sequel Dark Moon expanded the concept significantly, and Luigi's Mansion 3 on Switch is considered by many to be the series' peak. But there's something special about the original – its compact design, focused vision, and launch-title ambition make it a unique experience in Nintendo's library.


The Verdict

Luigi's Mansion is a delightful, atmospheric adventure that showcases Nintendo's creativity at its finest. While the short playtime holds it back from true greatness, the polished gameplay and unforgettable charm make it a must-play for any GameCube owner.

8
gameplay
8
controls
8
visuals
9
audio
9
value
7
The Good
  • Incredible atmosphere and lighting effects for its time
  • Unique vacuum-based gameplay that's genuinely fun
  • Luigi's personality shines through animations and voice clips
  • Portrait ghost boss battles are creative and memorable
  • Stunning graphics that still hold up today
The Bad
  • Very short - can be completed in 4-6 hours
  • Limited replay value outside of Hidden Mansion mode
  • Some backtracking can feel tedious
  • No multiplayer options
Game Details
  • Platform: GameCube
  • Developer: Nintendo EAD
  • Publisher: Nintendo
  • Genre: Action, Adventure
Price Guide
LOOSE
$35-45
CIB
$55-70
SEALED
$200+
No retail data available for NA.
More Reviews
Animal Crossing: New Horizons
9/10
New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe
8/10
Wii Sports
9/10