New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe Review

"The definitive 2D Mario experience on Switch bundles two great games with new playable characters. While not as innovative as its contemporaries, it delivers solid platforming that's perfect for multiplayer sessions."

By Anthony Micallef Published on 1/11/2019

The Best of the 'New' Series

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe represents the pinnacle of the 'New' series that began on the DS in 2006. While the art style and music have worn thin after four entries, the level design and gameplay mechanics are the most refined they've ever been.

This Switch port bundles New Super Mario Bros. U with New Super Luigi U, essentially giving you two complete games. That's over 160 courses of platforming goodness, making this one of the most content-rich Mario games available.

Classic Mario, Perfected

If you've played any 2D Mario game, you know what to expect: run, jump, stomp enemies, collect power-ups, and reach the flagpole. What elevates NSMBU is the exceptional level design. Each world introduces new mechanics and challenges that build on each other expertly.

The controls are pitch-perfect. Mario responds exactly as you expect, with the precise physics that make Nintendo platformers so satisfying. The spin jump, ground pound, and wall jump all feel natural, and pulling off tricky maneuvers is genuinely rewarding.

New Characters, New Options

The 'Deluxe' additions come in the form of new playable characters. Toadette can use the Super Crown to transform into Peachette, gaining a double jump and slower falling speed. Nabbit, previously a New Super Luigi U exclusive, is now available in the main game – he can't use power-ups but is immune to enemy damage, making him perfect for younger or less experienced players.

These accessibility options are welcome additions that make the game more approachable without compromising the challenge for veterans. You can still attempt the brutally difficult New Super Luigi U levels as Mario if you're seeking a real test.

Multiplayer Madness

Up to four players can tackle the adventure together, and it's absolute chaos – in the best way. Players bump into each other, steal power-ups, and accidentally (or intentionally) knock each other into pits. It's simultaneously frustrating and hilarious, and it's some of the most fun you can have with friends on a couch.

The bubble mechanic, which lets struggling players float safely until a teammate pops them free, helps keep everyone in the action without the constant game overs of previous multiplayer Mario attempts.

The Price Question

The elephant in the room is the price. This is a 2012 Wii U game with relatively few enhancements, yet it launched at full price. If you've already played these games extensively, there's little reason to double-dip. But for the millions who skipped the Wii U entirely, this is an excellent way to experience what many consider the best 2D Mario game of its generation.


The Verdict

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe is a polished, content-packed platformer that's easy to recommend for Switch owners who missed the Wii U era. While it plays things safe, the tight controls and excellent level design make it a reliable good time.

8
gameplay
8
controls
9
visuals
7
audio
7
value
8
The Good
  • Two full games in one package (NSMBU + NSLU)
  • Tight, responsive controls that feel great
  • Excellent level design with good variety
  • Toadette and Nabbit make the game more accessible
  • Great for local multiplayer chaos
  • Challenge Mode extends replay value significantly
The Bad
  • Visually dated 'New' series art style
  • Soundtrack is disappointingly generic
  • Wii U port with minimal enhancements
  • Full price for a 2012 game is questionable
Game Details
  • Platform: Nintendo Switch
  • Developer: Nintendo EPD
  • Publisher: Nintendo
  • Genre: 2D Platformer
Price Guide
CIB
$40-50
CIB
€40-45
DIGITAL
$59.99
More Reviews
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller
10/10
Wii Sports
9/10
Tetris 99
8.5/10